5,885
edits
Board/Minutes/2024-05: Difference between revisions
→2024/Res09 Approve active contributor membership application #2024031510000064: Added result (did not pass), votes and comments
m (Removed duplicate of Res19) |
(→2024/Res09 Approve active contributor membership application #2024031510000064: Added result (did not pass), votes and comments) |
||
|
|-
|style="text-align: left; background: white;" | <span style="color: black;">
'''
'''4 votes against''': <br>
- <u>Mateusz Konieczny</u> ''(Thanks for mapping! For purely mapping contribution there is an automatic qualification for 42 days of mapping within last year. This manual applications with a vote are rather for people who contribute in way other than mapping. If there are such significant contributions, I do not see them listed. I would encourage you to actively contribute by mapping and apply when 42 days of mapping are reached. Or submit a new application clearly listing them.)''. <br>
- <u>Sarah Hoffmann</u> ''(I agree with Mateusz' response.)''<br>
- <u>Craig Allan</u> ''(The applicant mapped 5 days in the last year, so doesn't meet the 42 days rule. The requirement for other non-mapping contributors is for the applicant to explain how they taught or recruited or guided or organised other OSM mappers. We need to see how they did something to build and support the broad OSM community. I'd guess that the applicant has done a lot of good work, but just didn't provide the right information. I suggest they could gather that information and then re-apply.)''<br>
- <u>Roland Olbricht</u> ''(I would agree with Craig. The information sounds like they instructed lots of mappers, but I have not been able to find any by following the provided links. Might profit from reapplication about who mapped in the end and how those people profited from the applicant's work.)''<br>
'''1 vote in favour''':<br>
- <u>Arnalie Vicario</u> ''(References shared by the applicant shows his other contributions - from september 2023 up to this year, showing his eagerness to contribute and participate more in OSM activities.)''<br>
'''2 did not vote: '''<br>
- <u>Daniela Waltersdorfer</u><br>
- <u>Guillaume Rischard</u>
|-
| ''Application initially processed by the [[Membership_Working_Group|Membership Working Group]]''.
| |||